Friday, June 19, 2009

Don't Die Trying

Everyone here who reads this blog understands that my goal in blogging was first to vent my frustrations to an audience who understood my angst and second, to for once, speak the truth about daycare. I wanted providers to feel like they are not alone and parents to understand that we are just people - people with limitations, biases and flaws. We are not the rosy-cheeked Norma Rockwell portrayal of witless but exorbitant happiness all the time. I believe that is it time for us to become transparent. To allow others to see us as the people we are and accept us as such.

My philosophy of honesty and integrity leads me to become frustrated when I see others who always strive to say the right thing rather than the truth. Nothing makes me more upset then to witness people who rob themselves of the freedom of voicing their true feelings and objectives. I suspect this is the reason that when I saw the following topic headline, "Do You Treat Them All The Same?", on a message board I couldn't resist reading the responses.

It astonishes me how many providers can not admit the truth of this question. I'm quite certain, as well, that many of them have grown so accustomed to saying what is societally correct that they can no longer identify the lies they tell themselves. For example, a number of providers answered that post claiming to have as much love and admiration for the children they care for as their own. Lies, lies, lies.

I once had a client interview with me who asked me this same question. She wanted to ensure that, "You will treat him exactly as you would your own children, right? How do I know that will happen?". Well, I had to tell her the truth. Needless to say she didn't call back. And, really, who could fault her for the question? I understand, with complete clarity, the reasons behind her asking such a loaded question. My sympathy to her as I know that whomever she did place her child with undoubtedly lied - whether outright or subconsciously.

If you are reading this and in complete disagreement I will ask you to take a minute, clear your head and look away from the computer. When you come back I want you to read the question that will follow and answer in the most honest, truthful, one second response you can. Look away now.......

The Question:

If you had multiple children in your care and they, and your own child were all playing together in the same room and the house caught on fire who, of all of those kids, would you take to safety first?

See? Do you REALLY love the children in your care on the level you love your own? If you answered anything but your own child then I feel deeply sad for your child. Because, if their own parent isn't willing to risk life or limb for them over anyone else then they truly have no advocate in life.

Sure, we can like the kids in our care. We can even love them. And, we would certainly see that, they too, got to safety. But the fact remains that you will never love them on the same level you do your own. I challenge you to really think about that question. Push all the societal pressures to be perfect, unbiased and equally loving and just be real. For once, be real. Yeah, it's hard at first isn't it? There is no reward for being real. Real is not popular. But real saves your child in that house fire.

So, my real, truthful, and uncalculated answer to that thread question is that NO, I don't treat them the same. Yes, I expect my children to share their cookies with them rather than eat a treat in front of the kids. Yes, I expect my own child to share a toy brought into the daycare space as I would any child bringing a toy from home. But, in a lot of ways they are treated much differently. My kids don't go to work every day - I do. Regardless of the fact that this is my business it will always be their home first. I wouldn't expect them to act as though they were in daycare all day. If I wanted that I would close my doors and plunk them in someone else's care.

Reality is blissful. Honestly, it is. Fooling yourself just causes guilt and regret. When you try to live up to societal standards of what is pretty and correct and acceptable, even when only in your own mind, you will die trying. You'll never get there. It is a stairway with no landing in sight. Stop being who everyone else wants you to be. Start being you. Answer these questions with honesty and clarity. Pass these truths along to the kids you care for. Teach them that happiness does not include lying to yourself to please others. Teach them that pleasing others means never pleasing yourself. Your self reflection and honesty therein will open doors for them in the future. Go back and answer that question again and feel privileged to speak the truth. There is no glory in being someone you're not.



For concerns, advice or suggestions I welcome your email at judytrickett@yahoo.ca

6 comments:

  1. I agree so wholeheartedly with this post! I do love the kids in my care (most of them...some of them just reach like status;), but I couldn't even measure that love on the same scale as the love that I have for my own child! I DEFINITELY and ADMITTEDLY treat my daughter (she's 2) differently than the rest of the children. I decided to stay at home and NOT go back to work, so that I could be a SAHM with my children. Like you said, she's expected to share and is held to the same consequences as any other child if she misbehaves. But she's the one I snuggle and spend an extra 5 minutes with before naptime, she's the one who can come into the kitchen and help me make lunch so we have 1 on 1 time. If parents ask, I'm honest. And if they have a problem with it, my advice would be to stay at home and open your own daycare...because your children only have 1 set of parents, and no one else is going to love and nurture them like you do. And yeah, if they say they are, they're lying!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I strongly disagree. I am not lying when I say that I treat the children in my care pretty much the same as my own. I don't claim to love them as my own, I am not their parent. I am however their caregiver, and I care very very much about them and their feelings. There is an equal amount of nuturung and effection and fairness in my childcare.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Apparently my fingers don't work today. "nuturing and affection" I meant.

    ReplyDelete
  4. When you mention being asked by a potential client about will their kids be treated the same way as your own what pops to mind with me is this: Yes, they will be treated the same as mine. They will be expected to use their manners, show respect to me, the others in my care and my home. I tell them about my discipline which will basically be time outs for those old enough to receive them. The difference with me is I did spank my own children when they were younger. Of course I'm not going to spank a daycare child. Most parents were fine with this and understood, and I don't think I shocked anyone in the past letting them know I did spank my boys when they needed it. They all seemed to be on the same page with me. And as for what I'd do if my house was on fire....well we'd all be going out together, ever single one of us. Thankfully my own children are at school for most of the day but I'm proud of my boys and I know that if they were home when a fire broke out in our home, they would be rescuing the little ones with me. Having them grow up in my home with all these extra little ones has taught them a lot of compassion and love towards others, even though they may not show it to me at times, it's there and I'm happy about that :)

    Another great post Judy!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with your post (yet again). I think this difference in how I feel about my own kids compared to my dc ones is most noticable to me when a child has one of those narrow escapes. Like, one is at the top of the slide but instead of sliding down, decides to lean over the edge and almost falls. No matter who the kid is, your heart drops into your stomach for a sec. But once I can breath again (after I make the save) if I examine the source of my fear I would have to admit that if it's my kid at the top, I am worried about their safety because I love them and never want them to feel pain.If it's a child in my care up there then, while I don't want them to have a bad fall either, my foremost concern is in truth that I don't want to have to report a serious occurence (I am licensed) and have to call a parent and try to explain an injury to them. I know this sounds callous but these kids are my job, their safety is my job and as long as I am providing the best environment and supervision I can then the parents will have to be content with that and know that if they want someone to just love their child all day, maybe they should give up their job and stay home themselves.They have the same choice I do and both sides have to make sacrifices in order to live the life they choose.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Um, as far as loving a daycare child as much as my own....it really depends on the day. My own kids certainly push my buttons......j/k! Of course I love my kids more then ANYTHING or ANYBODY in this world. Sorry daycare kids, but I didn't go through the birthing or adoption process with you.

    ReplyDelete