Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Daycares Don't Care

There is an interesting site I came across many years ago. The name of the site is Daycare's Don't Care. This site was created by, what I can assume, is a mother who is anti-daycare. It might seem strange that as a daycare provider I am including information about an anti-daycare site on my blog. And stranger still is that I think the site has some merit. There are many points of concern and comment that are undeniably true.

I visit this site often. I like to read any new articles on the detrimental effects of daycare on children. It has been known for many years that the younger a child enters daycare and the more hours a child spends in non-family care the more aggressive that child will be or become. These are not opinions - they are fact. And Daycares Don't Care is quick to point this out.

The other section of this site that is interesting are the comments by daycare workers. I encourage you to pour yourself a cup of coffee and browse those comments. You might be surprised by how true those comments are and how many of them ring true in your own head. If anything, those comments, made by real, honest to goodness people, tell the real story of daycare. Some of those comments are resentful, some of them insightful, but most of them are simply sad. These comments, more than anything I have ever read about daycare are true. Granted, a lot of these comments refer to commercial or centre-based daycare and not the home daycare environment but all in all they do not paint a very pretty picture.

The main objective of the site owner can be found in the header of the site's title - How Can A Daycare Love? And I think the site does a fairly good job of dispelling the myth that anyone, other than a parent can truly love a child with the same capacity. And children need, above all, love. Not just a passing love that consists of compassion or empathy but an unbridled love. A love so great their caretaker would risk life and limb for them above all others. And, as asked by the site, can this level of love be found in daycare?

Some of my favourite comments:

I know most of the children at my daycare seem happy, but I also see a loss because they are not with their parents very much. I do agree that being in a place for 11 to 12 hours, 5 days a week without your mom or dad has to be so hard emotionally.


I have done Daycare in my home...it may sound ironic but I agree with a lot of the views on your site.
I feel sorry for the kids that are at my house from 7am to 6pm on the dot.
...I try to show love to the kids that I watch, but when you have 4-6 of them...it can be hard.
I would NEVER put my own kids in daycare.


...As far as the feelings toward the children in the daycare where I worked, I freely admit that I did not and could not care as deeply for the children as their parents. In fact, as...I speak with brutal honesty, there were children that I was very fond of and others that got on my last nerve on a regular basis. Many of my co-workers admitted that they felt the same way. I can not say truthfully that I LOVED any of them...


Seem heartless? Maybe. But how many of them, if you thought long and hard ring true in some small way or another? Sadly, this site points out the undeniable truth. And I am for the truth regardless whether it is disadvantageous to me or not.

Daycares Don't Care
has hit an raw, uncovered nerve in a way that exposes truth and asks real people to back up that truth. And surprisingly, it is the very people being paid by the industry who are breaking the silence. And to them I offer kudos for having the fortitude to stand up and speak the unpopular notion that daycare is great for society. It never was and it never will be.

Yes, I provide care to children. And, despite what you might have just read I will continue to do so. It seems counter intuitive to provide care while singing the praises of sites like Daycares Don't Care. But the simple fact is that nothing I say, or others like me might say, will change the reality that children all over the world will show up at daycare tomorrow. And I know that what I provide for those children far surpasses the environment and care level where many other children spend their days. So for now, I will give what I can to those I can legally care for. At least in some small way I am ensuring that five children will not be forced to spend their days in some of the care situations commented on by those daycare workers on Daycares Don't Care.

Maybe one day we will all wake up and realize that we don't need to live the way we do. That we don't need multiple vehicles, the latest and greatest electronics, cellphones, extended cable packages, hair styles that cost more than our food bill and restaurant meals every single week. Maybe one day we will wake up and realize that the Jones' had it all wrong; that our children are more important than material possessions that make us feel good only until the newest version debuts wherein we will have to work overtime to afford it. But until then I'll continue to offer care because sadly, there are children who need it.




For concerns, advice or suggestions I welcome your email at judytrickett@yahoo.ca

9 comments:

  1. Great post Judy, I'll definately check out that site. Sometimes the truth hurts but it needs to be said and kudos to you for stating the obvious. I am also a child care provider and strive to provide a nuturing environment for 5 toddlers that would likely be stuck in front of the TV eating KD if they were somewhere else....
    Keep up the great work!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice post Judy. And all so true, it doesn't matter where the center is located they are all the same. Bare essential warehouses.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sad, but true. I love your last paragraph.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I disagree that all daycare centres are "bare essential warehouses", I live in a small town and used to work at the local, non-profit daycare centre. It was a great daycare, with mostly great staff. I do, however, agree that we as childcare providers can give excellent care, but it is not equal to the care or love of a parent. I only post anonymous because I don't understand how to do otherwise.
    On the flip side, and a totally different subject altogether, some kids are unfortunately better off in daycare than the care of their ill-equipped parents.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous above:

    If you wish to join as a "follower" there is a link on the right hand side of the page and when you log in your comments will automatically come up with your name and profile pic. Or, you can also always just add your name to the bottom of your comment when you are done typing it.

    Hope that helps.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think it is interesting that so many of us who provide home daycare do so (or at least start doing so)because we know our kids need us to be home and we will not put them in someone else's care. I would also like to think that I try very exhaustingly hard to provide excellent care every day to the children entrusted to my care. I know their parents feel guilt every day when they drop off and I want them to know their children ARE deeply cared for, safe, and happy. I think some moms are great moms because they do work and the moms I have balance things quite well. Instead of sites like the one you reference bashing parents for working, there should be more supports for them. In an ideal world, sure, maybe all moms would stay home. But that will never happen so people should get over it, and instead of negativity try supporting efforts in making daycares (home and centre-based) places where excellent care is provided every day.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Mustbenuts said: "In an ideal world, sure, maybe all moms would stay home. But that will never happen so people should get over it....."

    I think we are far too complacent as a society. Just because something has been occurring with increased frequency and societal acceptance does not make it "normal" or "okay". I think all too often we allow the fact that others are doing it to be factor in justifying behaviours or "norms". I think we need to be wary of "getting over things" and just allowing society to sway our thinking. The increasing numbers of people with children in daycare is not a "strength". We must be careful to give thought to every decision we make - especially when it concerns children - rather than follow the status quo.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I find it offensive that anyone would think that the majority of parents put their children in daycare for expensive hairstyles and restaurant meals, etc. I know far too many people who don't have a choice not to work. Which is worse...being in daycare or not eating? What about single moms?

    ReplyDelete
  9. I totally agree with mustbenuts. I have three kids who have been with everyday bc I work at a daycare and I wouldn't have it any other way! My kids love going to daycare bc its fun! I live in a small town and we all know each other and really don't have huge problems! I just don't think its fair to make " general" statements about ALL daycare. Ridiculous. It's just opinions that people try to push on other ppl. Sorry I have to work to maintain a life!

    ReplyDelete